Myths About Tax Audits - What's True and What's Not?

Aimee Pivott

The word “audit” can send shivers down the spine of even the most diligent business owner. But tax audits aren’t as mysterious—or as terrifying—as many people think. Let’s bust some common myths and clarify what’s really true.


Myth 1: Only Businesses That Do Something Wrong Get Audited Truth:
Audits aren’t always triggered by wrongdoing. The IRD uses random selection, data matching, and risk profiling to choose audit candidates. Even businesses with clean records can be audited.


Myth 2: If You Use Accounting Software Like Xero, You’re Safe From Audits Truth:
Using software like Xero helps keep your records organised, but it doesn’t make you immune. The IRD still expects accurate data entry, proper categorisation, and supporting documentation.


Myth 3: Audits Are Always a Nightmare Truth:
Audits can be stressful, but they’re manageable—especially if your records are in order. With a good accountant by your side, audits can be handled efficiently and professionally.


Myth 4: You’ll Be Fined Automatically If You’re Audited Truth:
An audit doesn’t automatically mean penalties. If errors are found, the IRD may issue reassessments or request corrections. Penalties typically apply only in cases of negligence or intentional non-compliance.


Myth 5: You Don’t Need to Keep Records If You’re Not Making Much Money Truth:
All businesses—regardless of size—must keep accurate records for at least seven years. This includes invoices, receipts, bank statements, and payroll records.


Final Thoughts:
Tax audits aren’t something to fear—they’re part of a healthy tax system. The best defence is good preparation: accurate records, timely filings, and a trusted accountant who knows your business.


A Timely Reminder: Consider Audit Shield Insurance

Even with the best preparation, audits can still happen. Audit Shield Insurance provides peace of mind by covering the professional fees associated with responding to an audit, review, or investigation instigated by the IRD.


It’s a smart way to protect your business from unexpected costs and ensure you have expert support when you need it most. If you haven’t already considered Audit Shield, now is a great time to talk to your accountant about whether it’s right for you.

By Aimee Pivott July 29, 2026
What New Zealand’s Holiday Pay Changes Mean for Employers and Employees After years of confusion, payroll errors, and costly remediation projects, New Zealand is set to replace the Holidays Act 2003 with a new employment leave framework designed to be simpler, clearer, and easier to administer. The Employment Leave Bill has now passed through Parliament, introducing significant changes to how leave is earned, taken, and paid. While the new law represents one of the biggest changes to leave entitlements in decades, it is important to note that the current Holidays Act remains in force during a transition period, with the new system expected to come into effect in 2028. Why Is the Holidays Act Being Replaced? The Holidays Act 2003 has long been criticised for being overly complex and difficult to apply, particularly for employees with variable hours, shift work arrangements, and changing work patterns. Numerous organisations across New Zealand have discovered holiday pay calculation errors, resulting in significant back-pay obligations to employees. The Government's goal is to create a leave system that is easier for both employers and employees to understand while reducing payroll compliance issues. The Biggest Changes Coming 1. Leave Will Accrue From Day One Under the current Holidays Act, employees generally become entitled to annual leave after 12 months of continuous employment and sick leave after six months. Under the new system, annual leave and sick leave will begin accruing from an employee's first day of work. This means employees will start building leave balances immediately rather than waiting for qualifying periods to pass. 2. Leave Will Be Measured in Hours One of the most significant reforms is the move away from calculating leave in weeks and days. Instead, leave entitlements will accrue and be tracked in hours. This change is expected to better reflect modern working arrangements, including part-time, casual, and flexible working patterns. 3. Employees Can Take Part-Day Leave Because leave will be recorded in hours, employees will have greater flexibility in how they use their leave. Rather than taking full days off, employees will be able to take only the hours they need. This could benefit employees who need time for appointments, family commitments, or shorter periods away from work. Workers can request to cash up to 25% of their annual leave balance, as at their last start date anniversary, up from the current maximum one week. 4. A Simpler Leave Payment System One of the most challenging aspects of the current law is determining the correct holiday pay calculation. Employers are often required to compare different payment methods to establish the correct amount. The new framework introduces a single hourly leave pay rate that applies across different types of leave, significantly simplifying payroll calculations. 5. Changes for Casual Workers and Additional Hours The new legislation introduces a 12.5% leave compensation payment for casual hours and additional hours worked beyond an employee's contracted standard hours. For many casual employees, this replaces the current 8% holiday pay model and may result in higher leave-related compensation being paid alongside wages. 6. Public Holiday Rules Will Be Clearer The legislation also introduces a revised "Otherwise Working Day" test, intended to make it easier to determine when an employee is entitled to public holiday benefits.  This is expected to provide greater certainty for employers managing employees with changing work schedules. 7. Bereavement and Family Violence Leave Access The new law also improves access to certain leave entitlements. Bereavement leave and family violence leave will be available from the start of employment rather than requiring employees to complete a qualifying period first. What Employers Should Do Now Although the new framework has been approved, employers are not required to change their current payroll systems immediately. The existing Holidays Act still applies, and businesses must continue complying with current leave and holiday pay requirements until the new legislation takes effect. However, employers should begin preparing by: Reviewing current payroll systems. Monitoring guidance from Employment New Zealand and MBIE. Understanding how hours-based leave accrual will affect their workforce. Planning future payroll and HR system updates. Continuing to address any historical holiday pay errors under the current legislation. What This Means for Employees For employees, the reforms aim to make leave entitlements easier to understand and easier to access. Leave balances will grow from day one, calculations should become more transparent, and workers with non-standard schedules may find their entitlements better reflect the hours they actually work. Final Thoughts The replacement of the Holidays Act marks a major shift in New Zealand employment law. By moving to an hours-based system, simplifying leave payments, and allowing leave to accrue from the first day of employment, the Government hopes to eliminate many of the compliance and payroll challenges that have plagued employers for years. For now, the key message is simple: the current Holidays Act still applies, but both employers and employees should start familiarising themselves with the upcoming changes to ensure a smooth transition when the new framework comes into effect.
Understanding the MSD Flexi-Wage Subsidy in New Zealand
Supporting people into sustainable employmen
By Aimee Pivott June 3, 2026
Understanding the MSD Flexi-Wage Subsidy in New Zealand Supporting people into sustainable employment is a core focus of New Zealand’s Ministry of Social Development (MSD). One of the key initiatives designed to bridge the gap between job seekers and employers is the Flexi-Wage Subsidy. This programme plays an importan
Governance isn’t corporate red tape — and it’s not just for big companies.
For SMEs, governance is s
By Amber Rowsell May 4, 2026
Governance isn’t corporate red tape — and it’s not just for big companies. For SMEs, governance is simply how decisions are made, monitored, and held accountable as the business grows. It’s not just compliance. Even the Institute of Directors in New Zealand makes it clear governance is about strategic oversight and lon
Now’s a great time to get started on our end of year questionnaires — before the months fly by and t
By Aimee Pivott April 23, 2026
Now’s a great time to get started on our end of year questionnaires — before the months fly by and the job takes four times as long!
If you or someone you know has a promising business idea but limited financial resources, you may qu
By Aimee Pivott April 19, 2026
If you or someone you know has a promising business idea but limited financial resources, you may qualify for WINZ support benefits created to assist New Zealanders in launching and developing their businesses. Starting or growing a business in New Zealand can be exciting — but it can also be financially tough, especia
Stocktakes aren’t just a tick‑box task — they’re essential for protecting your financials.
By Aimee Pivott March 31, 2026
Stocktakes aren’t just a tick‑box task — they’re essential for protecting your financials.
1. No Claims Discount is ending 

The No Claims Discount will be discontinued because it hasn’t ac
By Aimee Pivott March 9, 2026
1. No Claims Discount is ending The No Claims Discount will be discontinued because it hasn’t achieved the intended health and safety improvements and has required subsidising from other businesses. What’s changing: Levy invoices will no longer include a 10% discount or a 10% loading based on claims history
As the financial year wraps up, it’s a good time to check in on KiwiSaver, especially with several i
By Amber Bates March 3, 2026
As the financial year wraps up, it’s a good time to check in on KiwiSaver, especially with several important changes coming over the next few years. Some affect how much you contribute, while others change what the Government puts in.
Depreciation might sound like an accounting buzzword — but it plays a HUGE role in your financial
By Aimee Pivott February 25, 2026
Depreciation might sound like an accounting buzzword — but it plays a HUGE role in your financial
Starting a new financial year is a great chance to get on top of your cashflow and make sure the bus
By Jeff Rowsell February 17, 2026
Starting a new financial year is a great chance to get on top of your cashflow and make sure the bus
More Posts